Carlsen's election in November 2025 completed a historic Latino majority on the Salt Lake City Council -- 4 of 7 seats held by Latinos, a first for any major city council in Utah. She was then named Vice Chair alongside Chair Alejandro Puy, creating the council's first all-queer, all-Latino leadership team. The council also holds first-ever female and LGBTQ+ majorities.
Won District 5 with 65.7% of the vote (2,838 votes) in Round 1 of ranked-choice voting, defeating Amy Hawkins (31.0%) and Vance Hansen (3.3%). Replaced Darin Mano who did not seek re-election. Latino majority came just six years after SLC elected its first minority council member, Ana Valdemoros, in 2019. Not up for re-election until 2029.